A weathered brick fireplace with an oak mantel beside a tall divided-light window in a welcoming living room.

Sawmill Tap Room's Old Fireplace Is Staying. Here's What Longleaf Swine Is Building Around It.

In September 2025, Longleaf Swine co-owner Adam Cunningham told The News & Observer that his team would "completely gut it and renovate it and kind of start brand new" at the old Sawmill Tap Room in North Raleigh. "We just don't want people to walk in and think that we just put our new sign on there," he said.

Eleven months later, Raleigh Magazine published the design. The cabin-like bones were still there, and so was the original stone fireplace. Designer Dusty Slemp had decided to lean into Sawmill's existing character, giving the room a warm, '70s-style lodge look. The plan started as a fresh build and ended up as a restaurant built around the room that drew the loudest regret when Sawmill closed. If you live in Stonehenge and Greystone Village at Lead Mine and Sawmill roads is your nearby errand stop, that shift tells you more about the restaurant coming in than any menu does.

Twenty-Three Years, Then a Long Dark Stretch

Sawmill Tap Room closed in May 2023 after 23 years as a North Raleigh neighborhood bar and restaurant. Raleigh Magazine reported that the owners were "shocked and heartbroken" when the landlord declined to renew their lease amid roughly $1 million in interior renovation demands they couldn't take on.

The building then sat empty for about two and a half years. In the same piece, Raleigh Magazine described a "collective frustration" over a long-running neighborhood staple being pushed out only to sit vacant. It added that the Tap Room's distinct character was what people missed most.

That's where the story starts. What got lost in 2023 was a specific room, and the people who missed it were missing the feel of that room as much as any one dish.

How "Start Brand New" Turned Into "Keep the Fireplace"

Longleaf Swine's team spent months in talks before signing. Raleigh Magazine reported that negotiations ran from February 2025 until the deal was inked that September, with brokers from Elm Partners helping the restaurant find the space. The opening target, and the plan for the building, both changed over the next year.

When Who reported it Opening target Plan for the building
Sept. 2025 Raleigh Magazine "Next fall" "A full gut and glow-up" with a total renovation
Sept. 2025 The News & Observer Fall 2026 "Completely gut it" and "start brand new"
Oct. 2025 CBRE lease announcement Summer 2026 Cunningham: "breathe life back into a cherished neighborhood location"
Aug. 2026 Raleigh Magazine "By the end of the year" Keep the cabin bones and the original stone fireplace

Even in CBRE's October 2025 announcement of the lease, Cunningham was already talking about bringing a cherished place back to life. By the time renderings came out, the design matched those words. Chef Dave Mitchell told Raleigh Magazine what the team kept hearing:

"What we've heard from a lot of people is they want that watering hole—that neighborhood bar kind of feel they can latch onto as their last stop of the night or the place they can go hangout. And we want to lean into that."

Mitchell also said the team wants to "be thought of more as a neighborhood restaurant, not just a barbecue spot." That's the same role Sawmill played for 23 years. The wording of the plan softened from "start brand new" to keeping the fireplace, and the purpose moved closer to what was there before.

What's Going Into the Room

Raleigh Magazine reports the new space at roughly 4,700 square feet, about three times the size of Longleaf's downtown restaurant. The October 2025 leasing announcement put the freestanding building at 4,514 square feet. Either way, that's enough room to split the building into several different spaces:

  • Main dining room, for lunches and family dinners
  • Cocktail lounge, which will also host private dinners, bourbon tastings and classes
  • Indoor-outdoor bar and patio
  • Grab-and-go market, inspired by Longleaf's popular holiday takeout meals and stocked with merch, sauces, pimento cheese, chicken salad and reheatable pork and brisket

Beverage Director Walker Roberts described the varied layout as a deliberate choice that lets Longleaf become the neighborhood's "third place." Slemp put it more simply: "We want people to mosey through the space."

The menu adds dinner without dropping what made Longleaf's name. The signature sandwiches and sides stay at the center. New entrees include steak frites, pork and lamb shank, a catfish fry, salads and braised meats, alongside a whiskey program and a cocktail list. General manager Johnny Berry summed up the tone: "It's not 'pinky out' barbecue. It's still barbecue."

The 2025 announcement also said the building will house Longleaf's catering operations. It mentioned weekly specials like Noodle Night and Fish Fryday, too.

The Brand Has Done This Before

Longleaf has already taken over an older building once. Its first restaurant opened in 2022 on East Edenton Street downtown, in a building that started out as a Texaco gas station and later housed Oakwood Cafe. The News & Observer noted that Southern Living named it one of the best new barbecue restaurants in the South the year before that September 2025 report.

The North Raleigh building is the second time Longleaf is working inside a space with its own history, and there's a third on the way. The team is also opening a Longleaf in the former Luna Rotisserie and Taproom in Carrboro. Slemp told Raleigh Magazine they're letting "the spaces and neighborhoods dictate what that vibe is going to be like." Seen that way, keeping Sawmill's fireplace fits how this team has worked all along.

A Shopping Center That Already Has Regulars

Longleaf isn't arriving at an empty center. When the lease was announced in October 2025, Greystone Village was described as fully leased and anchored by a 35,000-square-foot Food Lion at the corner of Lead Mine and Sawmill roads. Its local food tenants include:

  1. Sola Coffee Cafe, named "Best Local Coffee House" by Midtown Magazine
  2. Gonza Tacos y Tequila, which Triangle Downtowner Magazine credited with the "Best Tacos in the Triangle"
  3. Two Roosters
  4. KAI Sushi & Sake Bar

That mix covers morning coffee through a sushi dinner. An evening watering hole with a patio and a takeout market fills a gap between them. "These are our people," Berry told Raleigh Magazine. "We very much want to be part of this community."

When the Doors Might Open

The most recent dated target is the one Raleigh Magazine reported at the end of August: open "by the end of the year." Over the past year, the published targets have ranged from fall 2026 in September 2025 reports, to summer 2026 in the October 2025 lease announcement, to year-end now. That's common for a full renovation of an older freestanding building, but it means the end-of-year date is best treated as a goal. On Longleaf's website, a social post shown on the homepage says demolition is underway and "the transformation has begun." The restaurant's site is the place to watch for an opening announcement.

North Raleigh hours haven't been posted yet. For reference, the downtown restaurant at 300 East Edenton Street is closed Monday and Tuesday and open Wednesday through Sunday from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., with Sunday brunch from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. If the new location keeps a similar schedule, plan around those two closed days.

If you have a Sawmill memory or you're curious how new places like this one are changing life near Stonehenge, I'd love to hear from you. Let's connect. Kendra Kohut

Work With Kendra

With personalized guidance, local market expertise, and a relationship-driven approach, you’ll have the knowledge and support you need to navigate your next real estate move with confidence.

Follow Me on Instagram